Live airfare from New York City to St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands — part of our Caribbean watchlist. We price JFK, LaGuardia and Newark to STT once a day, watch a public mistake-fare feed every hour, and check every fare against its own recorded history.
These are round-trip fares, so the return leg covers St. Thomas back to New York on the same ticket — booking the round-trip is almost always cheaper than two one-ways.
| Airport | Price | Typical | Discount | Stops | Total time | Airline | Dates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| JFK | $346 | $445 | -22% | 1 stop | 17h 33m | American Airlines | Nov 14 – Nov 21 |
| LGA | $464 | $436 | -0% | 1 stop | 17h 19m | American Airlines | Nov 14 – Nov 21 |
| EWR | $556 | $570 | -2% | 1 stop | 16h 47m | American Airlines | Nov 14 – Nov 21 |
Total time is the full elapsed duration of the cheapest itinerary we recorded, from departure to arrival with any connection included — not flight time. Read it alongside the stop count.
US Virgin Islands · Economy · Nov 14 – Nov 21
Cheapest round-trip on the live feed — 1 stop. Compared against typical fares for this region while we build 90-day history for the route.
US Virgin Islands · Economy · Nov 14 – Nov 21
Cheapest round-trip on the live feed — 1 stop. Compared against typical fares for this region while we build 90-day history for the route.
US Virgin Islands · Economy · Nov 14 – Nov 21
Cheapest round-trip on the live feed — 1 stop. Compared against typical fares for this region while we build 90-day history for the route.
Since we started tracking New York to St. Thomas on 20 Aug 2026 — 42 days and 151 recorded checks — the lowest round-trip we've logged is $309, the median is $496, and the high was $989. Today's cheapest live fare is $346 — 30% below our recorded median.
We probe a fixed travel window each day, so this is a running record of the fare itself — not a seasonal forecast or an advance-purchase recommendation.
Carriers we've recorded on this route: American Airlines. The mix changes as fares rotate and seasonal routes open and close — book a mistake fare directly on the airline's own site rather than through a reseller.
The cheapest round-trip we're tracking right now is $346 on American Airlines, departing JFK. Our recorded low for this route is $309. Fares change without notice — this reflects our last check.
Over 42 days of tracking, round-trip fares have run between $309 and $989, with a median of $496. Anything at or below $496 is a normal-to-good price; closer to $309 is a genuine deal worth booking quickly.
Right now JFK has the lowest fare we're tracking to St. Thomas, at $346. We watch JFK, LaGuardia and Newark together because the cheapest fare moves between them.
The cheapest fares we're tracking to St. Thomas today connect once or twice; we're not seeing a nonstop under our price threshold at the moment. That doesn't mean none exists — just that the nonstop isn't the cheapest option right now.
The cheapest itinerary we're tracking takes about 16h 47m from EWR on American Airlines, including a connection — time in the air is less than that. A nonstop, when one is available, is usually shorter.
Carriers we've recorded on New York to St. Thomas include American Airlines. The mix shifts as fares rotate and seasonal routes come and go.
We re-price JFK, LaGuardia and Newark to St. Thomas once a day from a live search, and check a public mistake-fare feed every hour. Each fare card shows exactly when it was last checked.
No. We track fares for reference only — every deal links out to the airline or a flight-search site to book. We don't handle payment, tickets or reservations. Always confirm the final price before you pay.
Or see the full 50-destination watchlist.